Duped - part 2 (Daniel meets Ben, Zach and Logan)

Special thanks to Daniel for the idea for this story! If you (yes, I mean you, the one who loves wrestling and fucking!) would like to meet the Ballbusting Boys and see yourself in a story please read this post for more details.

This is part 2 of 2. Read part 1 here.

Warning: Contains graphic homosexuality.

Featured in this story: Ben, Logan and Zach (click for pictures)

“Listen, asshole”, Logan said, looking Daniel in the eyes. “Why don’t you fight me and we’ll see who’s the bitch?”

Daniel laughed as Ben curled up in a ball, clutching his sore, spent balls, cum oozing out of his wrecked hole.

“My, my, you’re a cocky little dude”, Daniel grinned, looking Logan over. “You think you can handle me?” He flexed his muscles, his dick twitching with excitement.

Logan was boiling with rage but he managed to stay calm. “Loser gets fucked?” he said casually.

“Sure”, Daniel grinned, grabbing his dick by the base and smacking it against Logan’s thigh. “Can’t wait to fuck you, too.”

Logan smiled. “Yeah, we’ll see.”

Daniel chuckled. “Same rules as before: No hitting below the belt. Submission holds are okay.” He eyed Logan and smiled. “Let’s make this a little more interesting. Each person gets to make one additional rule and stake.”

Logan shrugged his shoulders. “What do you have in mind?”

A mean grin spread on Daniel’s face. “The loser must say the words ‘I submit.’ and be acknowledged by the other person to count. And the loser immediately gets another rematch with same rules.”

“Okay”, Logan thought for a moment. “Here’s my additional rule and stake: You wrestle naked. And the winner gets to choose who the loser wrestles next.”

Daniel’s eyes narrowed. “No hitting below the belt, remember?”


Logan smiled. “Yeah, I remember.”

Daniel took off his singlet, revealing his muscular body.

In the meantime, Logan went through Ben’s things and found a spare wrestling singlet. It was a little too large but not much, and Daniel couldn’t help but stare at Logan’s perfect bubble butt.

Even though he had just shot his load, Daniel had a raging erection. He licked his lips and grinned at Logan. “Alright.”

“Alright”, Logan said, smiling back at Daniel. “Let’s go.”

A second later, they were rolling around on the mat.

Zach watched them, his hands in his pockets, while Ben was curled up in a ball, moaning in pain, cum dripping from his gaping hole.

Logan was nowhere near as muscular as Daniel but he was quicker and more agile, and the first couple of minutes went by without an obvious favorite emerging.

Suddenly, while having Daniel in a painful cradle, Logan reached between his legs and grabbed his nuts, squeezing hard.

Daniel yelped in pain. “Hey, that’s against the rules!” he yelled. “No hitting below the belt!”

Logan twisted his nuts and squeezed harder, making Daniel scream from the top of his lungs.

“You’re not wearing a belt”, Logan grunted, grinding Daniel’s nuts in his hand. “Is he wearing a belt, Zach?”

“Nope”, Zach grinned. “No belt.”

“So it’s not against the rules”, Logan said cheerfully, following up the squeeze with a hard slap to the nuts.

Daniel roared in pain. His balls were not used to taking a beating, and the pain was crippling him.

“I give!” he shrieked.

Logan ignored him, landing a devastating punch to Daniel’s balls that made him howl in agony.

“I give!” Daniel yodeled.

“That’s not what we agreed on”, Logan said, punching Daniel’s rapidly swelling nuts once again and eliciting a high-pitched wail.

“I submit!” Daniel squealed. “I submit! I submit!”

“Well”, Logan said, grabbing Daniel’s nuts in a vise-like grip that made Daniel let out a gurgling scream. “If I remember the rules correctly, you need my acknowledgement, right?”

“I submit! I submit! I submit!” Daniel squeaked.

Logan chuckled and smacked Daniel’s ballsack hard with the palm of his hand. “Alright”, he said casually, letting go of Daniel and allowing him to curl up in a ball.

“Wow”, Zach chuckled. “Those balls of his are pretty weak.”

Logan stood next to him and they watched Daniel squirm on the ground, cupping his bare balls.

“Yup”, Logan grinned. “Pretty weak.”

Zach looked at him. “What happens now?”

“I get to fuck him”, Logan said matter-of-factly. “But I’ll save that for later.”

Zach chuckled.

“Alright, Daniel”, Logan grinned and squatted down next to him. “Remember what we agreed upon: The loser immediately gets another rematch with the same rules. And the winner gets to choose the loser’s opponent.”

Daniel let out a moan.

“Well, I choose Zach”, Logan grinned and looked up at the muscular blond hunk. He reached into Ben’s sports bag and found another one of Ben’s wrestling singlets. “Huh”, he chuckled. “How many of those has he got?” He shrugged his shoulders and handed it to Zach.

While Zach was busy stuffing his oversized dick and his huge balls into the singlet, Logan turned to him and smiled. “Remember the rules, Zach?”

Zach blinked. “Ummm…” He scratched his head and smiled weakly. “They’re a little complicated, right?”

Logan shrugged. “Not at all. No hitting below the belt.”

Zach nodded. “But he’s not wearing a belt so I can hit him the nuts.”

“Right. As often as you like”, Logan grinned.

“Yeah, got it”, Zach nodded. “What else?”

Logan chuckled. “The loser must say the words ‘I submit.’ and he must wait for his opponent to acknowledge his submission.”

Zach nodded. “Okay, got it. If he submits, I say no, and continue hitting him in the nuts. Yeah, I got it.”

“The loser immediately gets another rematch with same rules against an opponent of the winner’s choosing”, Logan continued. “And you get to choose another rule and stake.”

Zach stared at him. “Like… what?”

Logan grinned. “Like, you get to wrestle in a tag team”, he suggested with a wink.

Zach’s face lit up. “Oh yeah, that’s a great idea, let’s do that. We can hold his legs open and you hit him in the nuts. Great!”

Logan laughed. “Yeah, just like that.”

Daniel’s eyes opened in shock. “What---“

Logan ignored him. “And if you’re fighting in a tag team it’s only fair that the winner gets to tag team fuck the loser, right?”

Zach laughed. “Definitely. Yeah, very good.” He looked down at Daniel and scratched his head. “Do you think you can cram in your dick alongside mine? His ass might be too tight.”

Logan shrugged. “I’m sure we’ll find a way to make both our dicks fit in there.”

Zach nodded slowly. “Yeah, you’re right. Let’s do that.”

“Hey, guys! Guys!” Daniel looked up at the two blond hunks, a panicked expression on his pain-contorted face. “That’s not fair!”

Logan raised his eyebrows. “You’re kidding, right?” He pointed at Ben who was clutching his sore nuts, his face contorted in pain. “Maybe we should ask Ben if it’s fair. Ben, give us your opinion, please.”

Ben didn’t even open his eyes. “Sounds fair to me”, he mumbled.

Daniel sat up straight, his eyes darting around, trying to find an escape route. His nuts were aching like mad and he knew that he didn’t stand a chance against Logan and Zach – especially if they went for the weak spot that was dangling vulnerably – and a little swollen – between his legs.

“You’re not going to chicken out, are you?” Logan sneered, crossing his arms in front of his chest.

Daniel’s eyes narrowed. “Fuck you!”

“No, we’re going to fuck you”, Zach grinned and adjusted his crotch where his humungous dick was stretching the fabric of his singlet.

Daniel paled.

A moment later, he was on his back, screaming from the top of his lungs as Logan and Zach were splitting his legs, leaving Daniel’s crotch very vulnerable to their attacks.

Zach grabbed Daniel’s left nut, Logan grabbed Daniel’s right nut, and they started squeezing simultaneously, prompting Daniel to squeal and wail in agony.

“I submit!” he screamed from the top of his lungs, his voice cracking pathetically. “I submit!”

“Do you acknowledge that?” Logan grinned, pressing his thumb into Daniel’s right testicle as if he wanted to core it.

Daniel wailed in agony, his face contorted in pain, his mouth wide open, his eyes shut. Beads of sweat were running down his face.

“What?” Zach yelled, twisting Daniel’s left plum harshly.

Daniel’s voice rose an octave and his eyes filled with tears. “I submit! I submit! I submit!”

“Do you acknowledge that?” Logan repeated a little louder, his knuckles turning white as he flattened Daniel’s right nut in his strong hand.

Daniel shrieked like a banshee.

“What?!” Zach bellowed. “I can’t hear you!”

“Never mind”, Logan yelled. “I’ll tell you later when the noise has died down.”

“Okay!” Zach shouted, viciously kneading and twisting Daniel’s rapidly swelling nut.

Over the course of the next couple of minutes, while Zach and Logan were tag-teaming Daniel’s testicles, Daniel’s voice turned hoarse and throaty and his screams evolved into pitiful grunts.

“I submit”, he croaked. “I submit.”

Logan chuckled and nodded at Zach.

“Alright”, Zach said casually. “You lose.”

They let go of Daniel who curled up in a ball, moaning and groaning as he nursed his mangled manhood.

“The winner gets to choose his next opponent”, Logan said and smiled at Zach. “And he’ll have to fight him right away.”

Zach looked at Ben who looked like he had recovered from getting his nuts crunched and his butt fucked a little while earlier.

“You up for it?” Zach asked.

Ben nodded grimly.

“Okay”, Zach grinned. “Daniel, get up. You’re wrestling Ben next.”

The next couple of hours were a blur of mind-numbing pain and utter humiliation. There was a certain irony in the fact that Daniel had introduced the rule that lead to this situation. The three hot studs took turns wrestling Daniel, wrecking his nuts and causing the barely average-sized orbs to swell to the size of cantaloupes. With every match Daniel got weaker, until he was barely able to move.

His throbbing testicles were bright red and covered in nasty bruises. They looked huge, dwarfing his shriveled, pathetic dick that looked like it attempted to hide in his pubic hair.

Finally, after Ben had coaxed another barely audible “I submit!” out of Daniel, he looked at his friends, a mean grin on his face.

His mood had changed considerably. Even though his nuts were still beet red and swollen, and Daniel’s cum was still running out of his hole (“Damn, he must have dumped a gallon of jizz in there”, Zach had quipped, earning him a well-placed slap to the nutsack from Ben.), Ben’s dick was hard as a rock and ready for action.

“Let’s fuck the bitch now”, he grinned. “Let’s split him wide open.”

Zach laughed.

“You’re in the mood, huh?” Zach chuckled.

“Guys”, Logan said, pointing at Daniel who was

“Fuck, yeah, I can’t wait to bang the shit out of him”, Ben smiled, stroking his boner.

Before Daniel knew what hit him, his mouth was filled with Ben’s fat cock and Zach’s oversized schlong was knocking on his back door.

“Damn, he’s tight”, Zach mumbled, trying to push the fat head of his huge cock into Daniel’s tight butt.

“Wait”, Logan said and sent his fist crashing into Daniel’s nutsack.

Daniel let out a muffled grunt and his eyes opened wide as Zach’s dick slipped into his ass like a battering ram until his colossal balls smacked against his cheeks.

“There you go”, Logan chuckled. “A little hit in the nuts, and the hole opens like up a pretty little flower…”

Ben and Zach burst out laughing as they pounded Daniel at both ends while Logan was squeezing and kneading Daniel’s bloated ballsack.

Daniel’s muscular body was covered in sweat and he grunted and groaned as Ben reamed his throat and Zach deep-dicked his tight hole.

Logan crushed Daniel’s nuts with both hands, squishing and squashing the tender orbs and pressing his thumbs deep into the core of Daniel’s swollen balls.

After a couple of minutes, they changed positions.

Logan thrust his dick into Daniel’s hole that had been conveniently stretched by Zach’s mammoth cock. The sound of Logan’s balls smacking against Daniel’s ass echoed through the room, mixing with Daniel’s muffled grunts and groans.

Ben took over nut crushing duties and started squeezing and twisting Daniel’s beet red balls with great enthusiasm. There was a devilish smile on his face as he worked over Daniel’s swollen ballbag, kneading the tender orbs with all the force he could muster. Occasionally, he gave Daniel’s shriveled, pathetic dick a hard slap as to remind him that his masculinity was taking a serious beating.

At first, Zach had a little trouble getting all of his huge dick down Daniel’s throat, but he didn’t give up until he was balls-deep inside him. Daniel was retching and gagging, his lips stretching around the base of Zach’s thick schlong, his neck bulging with the fat head of Zach’s cock, drool running out of his mouth whenever Zach pulled his dick back.

None of them showed Daniel any mercy. He had forfeited any right to a merciful treatment after what he had done to Ben.

They used Daniel as a big, muscular sex toy, and they used him good and hard.

“Let me have a go at his hole”, Ben said cheerfully, smacking Daniel’s fat ballsack and making him let out a throaty grunt while Zach was pounding his mouth.

“Sure, man”, Logan grinned and pulled his dick out of Daniel’s muscular butt. He tapped Zach on the shoulder. “My turn, buddy.”

Daniel gasped for breath when Zach’s dick slipped out of his mouth.

“Please”, he croaked, his eyes filled with tears. “Plea---“

Logan shut him up by burying his dick balls-deep in his throat. He held Daniel’s head in place as he fucked his mouth aggressively.

Zach turned his attention to Daniel’s bruised ballsack.

“Damn, that looks horrible”, he chuckled, grabbing Daniel’s sack by the neck and smacking the tender, shiny orbs with the palm of his hand before sinking his fingers into the bloated meatballs.

After what seemed like an eternity, and after switching positions more than a dozen times, the guys were ready to shoot their loads.

Zach filled Daniel’s ass with a huge load of jizz, fucking his seed into him in deep, hard thrusts.

At the same time, Ben and Logan creamed Daniel’s face.

In a particularly vicious twist, they held his eyes open and aimed their dicks right at them.

Daniel was moaning and panting heavily, babbling incoherently as the salty spunk splashed onto his face, covering him with a thick, creamy layer of goo.

“I think we’re almost done”, Logan said, smacking his dick on Daniel’s cheek.

Daniel looked up at him, his eyes red and filled with tears and cum. “What do you want?” he whispered hoarsely.

“Apologize to him”, Logan said, pointing at Ben. “Apologize to him for being an asshole.”

“If I do, will you let me go?” Daniel whimpered.

Logan raised his eyebrows. And reached between Daniel’s muscular thighs, grabbing a good handful of his mangled manhood.

Daniel let out a throaty grunt.

“Apologize and we’ll think about it”, Logan said.

Daniel looked at Ben. “I’m sorry”, he mumbled.

“Tell him you’re sorry for being an asshole”, Logan said, squeezing Daniel’s nuts hard.

Daniel coughed, his face a mask of pain. “I’m sorry for being an asshole”, he sobbed.

Logan and Zach looked at Ben.

“Alright”, Ben said with a generous smile. “Apology accepted.”

Daniel closed his eyes and let out a long sigh.

“We’ll let you go”, Ben continued. “And we’ll meet here same time next week for another wrestling match. Three on one. Same rules.”

Daniel stared at him.

“Deal?” Logan asked, twisting Daniel’s nuts.

Daniel groaned in agony. “Deal!”

“Nice”, Ben grinned. “I’m looking forward to seeing you again.”

His buddies laughed.

They grabbed their things and walked out the room, leaving Daniel behind.

“That was pretty fun”, Zach said.

Ben chuckled. “I told you I’d kick his fucking ass.”

Zach and Logan laughed.

“What?!” Ben said. “I told you, right?”

“Yeah, you did”, Logan chuckled and put his arms around Ben’s shoulder. “And you were right.”

“I think we should invite some people over next week, have a little party, you know?” Zach suggested. “Maybe they want to fight him, too.”

The door closed behind them.

Daniel closed his eyes. He was breathing heavily. His eyes were burning and the scent of sperm filled his nostrils. Every fiber of his body was hurting. He tentatively reached between his legs, wincing as he touched his sore nuts. They felt huge and hot. His other hand traveled to his ass. His hole was gaping and dripping with Zach’s cum.

He let out a sigh.

Same time next week.

He was not looking forward to it...